Property Management

We Turn Property Owners Into Investors

WILMOTH Group has been providing premium property management service to Indianapolis and Central Indiana since 1994. As your local, family-owned property manager, we offer ethical and transparent property management and leasing services.
We use the latest technology and processes to help rental property owners in Central Indiana maximize on their investment. Our combination of family, ethics, transparency, technology, and affordable fees are the best solution for your property management and leasing needs.

Find out how much rent can you get for your investment

Let's Work Together to Improve Your ROI

Want to make more money from your property? Let’s team up! Our property management services are designed to boost your return on investment (ROI), making sure you get the most out of your property. Here’s how we help:

Property Marketing

Empty homes mean lost money for investors. We use proven marketing techniques to get your property the attention it needs and protect your earnings.

Tenant Screening

To avoid evictions, we make sure not to lease to the wrong tenant by carefully checking each applicant's background, keeping our eviction rates low.

Rent Collection

Stop wasting time chasing rent checks every month! Our electronic rent collection speeds up your cash flow by at least three business days.


We act as your advocate, ensuring maintenance, repairs, and renovations are completed quickly and at true market cost.

Property Inspections

We regularly inspect every home in our rental portfolio to spot any issues, enforce lease terms, and give you peace of mind.

Financial Reporting

As a WILMOTH Group client, tracking your financial performance is easy; we provide monthly reports and place all your statements in your online account.


We strive to prevent evictions and promise to select WILMOTH Group tenants with great care and diligence.

Lease Enforcement

Sometimes, we enroll tenants in our Behavior Modification program to address lease violations and give them a chance to correct their actions. However, tenants with consistent bad behavior do not qualify for this program.

Our Property Management Pricing and Fees

Many rental owners want to know the cost of hiring a property manager. WILMOTH Group believes in keeping our pricing clear and simple. While some property management costs can vary depending on specific property or tenant needs, our straightforward pricing covers most situations.

Monthly Management Fees

Our monthly management fee is 10% of gross rental income or $40 per unit, whichever is greater, with a discount to 9% or $35 for portfolios with 6 or more units. We charge a base rate because we continue to manage and maintain your property even when it’s vacant. This fee covers rent collection, fund distribution, maintenance management, and tenant care. We aim for transparency in our fees, especially since this area can be confusing for investors, and we want to ensure you understand the full scope of our services.

Tenant Finder Fee (TFF)

Our Tenant Finder Fee (TFF) is 75% of one month’s average rent, with a minimum of $500 and a maximum of $1500, for a one-year lease. For leases 18 months or longer, or those that are more complex, the fee ranges from 1.5 to 2 times the normal TFF. This fee covers the extensive work involved in marketing your property across major and minor websites, crafting descriptions, providing photos, managing 24/7 inquiries and viewings, screening applicants, and preparing and finalizing the lease. We aim to find you a well-qualified tenant, justifying this fee with the professional and comprehensive service we offer.

Lease Renewal Fee

Our Lease Renewal Fee is $250 for renewals of 6 months or longer and $125 for shorter renewals. This fee covers evaluating if a rent increase is needed, inspecting the property’s condition, checking tenant obligations, reviewing the market, and preparing and signing the new lease. This thorough process ensures all important aspects are considered during the lease renewal, which usually happens once a year.

Additional Fees

Payment Service: $10 per bill processed by WILMOTH
Additional Property Inspections (beyond move-in, move-out, and lease renewal): $100 per inspection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Buy and hold investment has two parts: rental income and the property’s value increase over time. While we can’t predict exactly when the value will rise, both factors determine your property’s worth. Unlike typical home sales valuations, rental property value is based on the income it generates and any equity increase. At WILMOTH Group, we help boost your income and suggest property upgrades to enhance its value growth.
As monthly rent payments are received, we systematically process your funds and deliver them to you each and every month. Electronically to your designated bank account to speed up the process. WILMOTH Group processes the receipt and accounting of funds the same way every month to follow our distribution schedule.
We have a strict process called underwriting to choose the right tenants and keep evictions low at 3%. Applicants are screened online, checking their credit scores, eviction and residence history, job and income, and any criminal records against our criteria. If they pass, we inform the property owner. This careful checking includes getting info from their current landlord about their lease, payment history, and behavior to make sure only responsible tenants rent from us.

When an owner wants to determine the funds they have available for distribution or for approved repairs that have not been billed yet with WILMOTH Group:

  1. Login to the Owner Portal
  2. Go to the Reports button on the upper right side of the homepage
  3. Select Rental Owner Statement
  4. Scroll to Available for Payment
  5. Click on the Accounting Menu Option on the top of the page
  6. Select Bills
  7. Filter for Unpaid Bills. These Unpaid Bills will not show on the Rental Owner statement.
  8. Subtract the Unpaid Bills from the Available for Payment. This is the balance available for distribution or for approved repairs that have not been billed yet.
We hope you will always be our client, but of course, things happen. When a decision is made to terminate management there are a number of steps to be taken. Most of these involve settlement of any outstanding bills. Due to the fact that utility companies and attorneys are slow to bill, we may have outstanding bills on your account. While we will due all we can to expedite the closing of the account, please plan that the process may take up to 45 days to disburse your final payment from your account.
Our tenant move-in process ensures we record your property’s condition accurately, urging owners to have the home ready for move-in. If tenants find any issues in the first week, they can report them without worrying about being charged or it affecting their security deposit. We document everything with photos before handing over the keys to maintain a clear record of the property’s state.

Visit the Owner Portal and login. Click on the Rental Owner tab. All of your relevant documents (agreements, leases, manuals, addendums) can be found ready for download.

To get signatures from owners far away, we’ve moved from using mail to faster methods. Nowadays, owners can print, sign, scan, and email documents back to us, or use a free program to create a pdf. We’re also looking into electronic signatures, like Docusign, which are becoming more common and can track who signed the document online.
We offer a web-based owner portal that you will gain access to when you first sign up with WILMOTH Group. When you log in, you will be able to see information on your properties, and over 20 different financial reports that will allow you to see performance on as frequent of a basis as you desire. The really great part of this owner portal is that you can review your investments performance in many ways, up to the minute, whenever you want! These reports may be printed or saved as a pdf file on your computer. Updated daily, and always available, WILMOTH Group transparency starts with your Owner Portal.
The rental owner statement report helps owners see their property’s cash flow, income, expenses, and more for a specific time. WILMOTH Group has a detailed guide with pictures to help owners understand this report, available on our website.
We finish our monthly accounting by the 14th of the next month and then email you about any money we send you. If you don’t get an email about money, it could be because the rent wasn’t paid, the payment is still processing, repairs are happening, or the property’s expenses were more than its income. You can check the Tenant Report and Rental Owner Statement in your owner portal for more details on payments and property cash flow.
WILMOTH Group uses an after-hours emergency dispatch service to ensure tenants get help with urgent issues like no heat or broken pipes, even on holidays or in the middle of the night. This service has trained property managers ready to assist or send help, ensuring your property is protected without depending solely on your manager’s availability. If the emergency involves fire, crime or loss of life Call 911 Immediately!
Through Buildium, WILMOTH Group’s owner portal, you can easily access your property’s documents, payment history, and reports anytime, anywhere. Lacy Clark from our team highlights how Buildium provides real-time insights into your property’s financials and tenant activities, including rent payments and maintenance expenses. This platform is especially useful for our out-of-state or overseas owners, offering detailed financial overviews and the ability to communicate directly with us for any queries.
WILMOTH Group helps owners get damages judgments during evictions or when there are unpaid rents or damages, costing around $300. We create a report showing unpaid rent plus any damages, minus the security deposit, and add legal fees to figure out the total amount to ask from the former tenant. This total amount is then given to a collector who may go after the tenant’s wages, and the judgment stays on the tenant’s record for seven years.
One of the biggest pain points for rental owners is how their property manager handles maintenance. How a property manager charges for maintenance is a concern that may not be obvious until it’s too late. With WILMOTH Group there is no reason for concern. We do not mark up these costs at all.
We ask owners to keep $300 in a reserve fund for each property to cover emergencies and small repairs. WILMOTH Group can use this reserve for repairs under $300 without needing to ask first. If there’s a big emergency and the reserve isn’t enough, we’ll need the owner to add more money to it.
Finding great tenants involves several steps, from figuring out who might rent the property to creating targeted ads. While signs and word of mouth are useful, over 90% of renters use the internet to find homes. WILMOTH Group goes beyond traditional methods by listing your rental on over 75 websites, reaching more potential tenants.
Marion County Indiana landlords must participate in a registration of their homes with the City of Indianapolis. Beginning in 2015, landlords must use a new online landlord registration site. Any property owner failing to register their properties could be subject to a fine. The actual owner must create an account within this system. The owner then may register each property they own and also list parties that may be also considered responsible (i.e. a property manager). The benefit for out of state owners to listing a responsible party is many violation notices are sent via US Mail. A local representative will likely receive the violation with time to correct it where the owner may not receive until the day the penalty kicks in.
If you have previously registered your Indianapolis-Marion County property you will receive an email from the city. It will advise you of the need to renew your Indianapolis landlord registration. The system has been updated to allow an owner to add a local based property manager and an agent for service of process.
At WILMOTH Group, our tenants pay rent online, which speeds up your cash flow by at least three days. If there’s an issue like insufficient funds, we find out quickly, much faster than with traditional paper checks. We settle accounts and send payments to owners electronically by the 14th each month, and owners get an email notification about the transfer, with the funds taking up to three days to appear in their bank account.
In 2020, we had to become creative with inspecting occupied homes due to the pandemic. We designed our own system for giving a tenant the option to avoid having one of our team members come into their home. This virtual inspection also provides owners a video inspection instead of a photograph document.
United States tax laws are very specific about withholding requirements for anybody without a federal tax identification number. The below is directly from the WILMOTH Group management agreement. “Distributions to Owner will only take place upon completion of a United States federal W-9 tax form disclosing the federal tax identification numbers for all owners. Under United States tax law,(US Internal Revenue Code Sect. 1441- the deduction of a withholding tax on all fixed or determinable gross income shall be required of any non-resident alien individual, fiduciary, foreign partnership or foreign corporation unless exempt under provisions provided under said IRS Section.) WILMOTH Group is obligated to withhold 20% of all funds when a tax identification has not been received and submit those funds to the United States Treasury. If management services are begun with no federal W-9 form in receipt, OWNER agrees to pay an additional Twenty Five ($25.00) per month to account for the cost of such processing. MANAGER reserves the right to not offer any services in this Agreement if not in receipt of a W-9 form containing all OWNERS federal tax identification number.”
Get Your Free Rental Analysis
Curious how much your house could rent for? Don’t leave it to guesswork. Fill out the form below for your free, no-obligation rental analysis report.
WILMOTH Group Rental Analysis
WILMOTH Group Property Management