Who Is WILMOTH Group?

WILMOTH Group focuses on providing creative local solutions for a variety of residential real estate needs. Our primary clients are non-occupant owners and the buyers, renters, and vendors who assist us in meeting their goals.


Founded in 1994, WILMOTH Group is a privately held real estate firm headquartered in Indianapolis, Indiana and Fort Myers, Florida.  The company is owned by Jennifer and Joel Wilmoth.

Since the beginning, we have focused on providing alternative residential real estate solutions to non-occupant owners. Our primary clients are corporate and investment owners of residential real estate in Central Indiana and West and Southwest Florida.

Our experience and proven systems combine to offer a unique, dedicated, partner in your residential real estate acquisition, management, and disposition needs. Our partners include investors, hedge funds, mortgage servicers, outsourcers, and alternative disposition providers. Our corporate client roster includes government, private, and hybrid owners of residential properties.

Joel and Jennifer are family and community-oriented and have built the company with a team that shares those values. We are constantly seeking people to join us that share our priorities.


Our mission is to provide creative residential real estate solutions for residential property owners in throughout Indiana and Florida.

Our primary business lines include:

  • Residential Property Management and Leasing
  • Traditional Residential Brokerage-working with non-occupant owners and purchasers of residential properties
  • Default Servicing– REO Brokerage, Short Sales

WILMOTH Group pursues to benefit all company stakeholders by pursuing:

  • Lateral development of alternative business opportunities that are an outgrowth of our core business competencies. 
  • Geographical growth through expansion of our offerings to select strategic markets.


Integrity – We will provide our services with honesty and the highest ethical standards. We will not compromise our individual or corporate integrity for any reason.

Service – to our communities, clients, and customers, and associates

Stability – The success of our business will be determined by the performance of our people. Our staff and associates will be encouraged to balance their faith, family, community and self with those of their vocation.

Excellence – Our continued success relies on our ability to deliver our services at a level reflecting our high values and principles.

Respect – We will always try to understand issues from the perspective of those affected. Our responses will be measured based on the empathy gained.

Education – Accepting that the world does not stand still, and the need to learn never ends, we encourage all of our Associates to stay current in their learning and respect the new solutions that can come from knowledge gained.

WILMOTH Operating Principles

WILMOTH Group focuses on successfully providing solutions based in our Operating Principles. These Principles have guided us for over two decades to develop our expertise serving non-occupant owners of residential properties. In this niche we provide specific services associated with marketing and management. Our clients are a diverse group of owners varying from large institutions to the one property investor. Our success is often also achieved through associations with other real estate professionals, their clients, and our tenants. All are treated with the same respect and appreciation.

Our primary objective is to find solutions for our clients to accomplish their unique goals and objectives operating from the foundation of our principles.

Our operating principles:

Satisfaction – Strive to have 100% satisfaction as reported by our clients and customers.
Dependability – No matter what, do what we promise we will do.
Communication – Provide significant communication options to enhance successful interaction with the company and its Associates
Creativity – solving problems and offering unique and efficient alternatives to the existing status quo.
Consistency – results that are expected and solutions that work
Teamwork – By utilizing teams to implement our values and principles we acknowledge that a team can achieve more, and do it better, than any one person by themselves.
Implementation – Provide our clients, customers, staff and associates well documented systems in order to effectively provide solutions
Growth – A clear plan for company growth benefits our Associates, stakeholders, and clients. An environment that encourages personal growth provides for a healthier, happier, more productive team.
Evolution – Creating demand for our services beyond the markets we currently serve while willingly experimenting to find mutually beneficial solutions.

Frequently Asked Questions
Still have questions? Please check out or FAQ's page for more information.

Affiliations and Memberships

Jennifer and Joel Wilmoth, through WILMOTH Group, believe supporting our industry is important and a priority. As active volunteers, we have affiliations and memberships with the following organizations:


Members of the National Association of Residential Property Managers since 2005. We honor a strict Code of Ethics and are constantly learning and implementing best practices learned through this affiliation.

Affiliations and Memberships with multiple Realtor boards and MLS organizations
  • National Association of Realtors
  • Indiana Association of Realtors
  • Florida Association of Realtors
  • Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors
  • REALTOR Association of Greater Fort Myers and the Beach
  • Greater Tampa Board of Realtors
  • Sarasota Association of Realtors


Joel and Jennifer Wilmoth believe and support giving back to our communities. We support various Housing programs in Central Indiana and West/Southwest Florida.   Another passion for us are kids and WILMOTH Group sponsors a family every year during the holiday season to ensure their children are not forgotten. We also have supported area youth organizations for over 20 years.  Joel is very active in a youth baseball program in Indiana.

WILMOTH Group-Indianapolis
Based on 119 reviews
powered by Google
Levi Partin
Levi Partin
14:35 08 Oct 20
I highly recommend WILMOTH! Lacy has been a pleasure to work with! Communication has been second to none. She is very professional and trustworthy.
FitWoo Fitness
FitWoo Fitness
14:31 08 Oct 20
Love working with the Wilmoth Group! Small locally owned and very responsive. I have their cell phone numbers, we text and email weekly. They provide service that I can't do from out of state. They are great at helping me expand my portfolio and continue on my path towards retirement. Thanks for the help team!
Chris Dickover
Chris Dickover
14:19 08 Oct 20
Dealing with Lacy has been great. She is very detailed when doing her research and responds in a timely matter. I would recommend Wilmoth Group.
Chris Knox
Chris Knox
20:07 05 Oct 20
Very professional organization from the top down. Responsive to tenant needs, timely communication with owners, good use of technology to simplify and consolidate information when needed, and fair in every dealing we've had with them. They were the 5th PM we "worked" with in 6 years, and we never wanted to look for another.
Stephan Meister
Stephan Meister
16:54 14 Sep 20
My property management of choice for all my Indianapolis rental properties. I have been with them going on three years, now. I love their professionalism and they truly care about the tenants. This makes for less problems and more consistent cash flow. It also preserves the value in your properties over time. I especially love the detailed financial reports at tax time!
Erin Prete
Erin Prete
15:06 08 Sep 20
My office works with the Wilmoth group here in Orlando and has for many years. Jennifer is a pleasure to work with and always provides excellent customer service to her clients. She is professional, knowledgeable and makes our job as closing agent easy! If you are looking for a good agent who understands the market, understands the process and provides excellent customer service, call Jennifer =)
Pam Pratt
Pam Pratt
14:21 02 May 20
Highly professional property management company. After some disappointing experiences with other managers in Indy, Jennifer, Joel and the team at Wilmoth are proving to be a cut above the rest. As an out of state property owner, I value their experienced, attentive approach in maintaining the properties well while keeping positive communications and high standards in dealing with tenants. I value their input as well as their timely response to issues that may arise.
See All Reviews

Looking for a property manager in Central Indiana?

Get your investment to work for you with WILMOTH Group.

Im Interested!


Ready to rent your home or property? Let's schedule a time to talk. The experts at WILMOTH Group have more than 25 years of experience in property management in the Indianapolis area.

© 2020 Wilmoth